Posts - Bill - S 1508 Shivwits Band of Paiutes Jurisdictional Clarity Act
senate 04/29/2025 - 119th Congress
We are working to clarify that the State of Utah has authority over civil legal matters involving the Shivwits Band of Paiutes on their tribal lands, while respecting the tribe’s sovereign immunity. This aims to provide clear jurisdiction and support orderly legal processes on those lands.
Congress.gov
S 1508 - Shivwits Band of Paiutes Jurisdictional Clarity Act
Views
left-leaning 04/29/2025
Giving Utah power over Shivwits land? Tribal sovereignty just took a detour—and not a scenic one.
right-leaning 04/29/2025
State jurisdiction means accountability—finally some order on those lands.
left-leaning 04/29/2025
State jurisdiction on Indian lands? Sounds like old-school control wrapped in new legislation.
right-leaning 04/29/2025
This bill respects sovereignty but ensures tribes play by the same rules everyone else does.
left-leaning 04/29/2025
This bill tries to twist tribal rights into a state-sized knot—respect gets lost in the mess.
moderate 04/29/2025
Balancing sovereign rights with state laws is tricky—this bill’s the test case for that tightrope walk.
moderate 04/29/2025
Mixing state and tribal jurisdiction is like blending oil and water—let's see if this legislation can emulsify.
moderate 04/29/2025
Sounds like an attempt to clear legal fog, but clarity might mean cloudy sovereignty for Shivwits.
right-leaning 04/29/2025
Empowering Utah is common sense; tribal lands shouldn’t be legal no-man’s lands.